Punishing the Whole Class
“Punishing the whole class” is how many students and parents describe collective punishment in everyday language. Whether it’s missing recess, losing privileges, or enduring public lectures, the emotional weight of being punished for others’ actions is profound. This tag curates student stories and analysis that centre the lived experience of being collectively blamed in school.
-
Why collective punishment doesn’t work, based on scientific evidence
When we challenge collective punishment, defenders often fall back on one refrain: it works. They say it fosters accountability, motivates group norms, and deters misbehaviour. They claim it teaches responsibility. But what if these assumptions are not only unjust, but false? A peer-reviewed study published in Scientific Reports dismantles this defence. Titled Measuring the efficacy of…
-
Why collective punishment doesn’t work
Group punishment doesn’t fix behaviour – it just makes kids hate school, in The Conversation. explains that collective punishment might seem effective in achieving short-term compliance, but is both unfair and ineffective in the long run. This article explains: Key takeaway: Collective punishment may offer a quick fix, but it erodes trust and fails to…