hand icon with "End collective Punishment in BC Schools"
scales of justice

Accommodation is not a reward

If they say: We need to see him demonstrating more maturity before we can offer those privileges.

Say: Support is not earned through performance; it’s provided in order to make success possible. Equity means scaffolding—not gatekeeping—a child’s access to meaningful participation.

Legal grounding: Accommodations are proactive rights-based measures, not conditional incentives. Denial based on maturity violates the principles of inclusive education.

Schools sometimes frame accommodations as privileges that must be earned—offered only when a child behaves, performs, or complies with classroom norms. But accommodations exist to remove barriers, not as conditional treats. The legal framework makes this very clear: equity is a right under the Human Rights Code, not something handed out based on perceived effort or merit.

Key takeaways

  1. Accommodations are proactive, not punitive
    Accommodations are designed to anticipate and remove barriers before they become entrenched. They are not a response to good behaviour, but a recognition of diverse needs from the outset.
  2. Equity is not performance-based
    A child does not need to prove themselves worthy of access. Supports are not earned—they are required by law to ensure equal opportunity, especially when the disability creates structural challenges.
  3. Denying accommodations on behavioural grounds is discrimination
    Withholding access because a student is dysregulated, immature, or “not trying hard enough” misuses accommodations as leverage. The law protects against this kind of gatekeeping.

Learn more

Part 1: Duty to Accommodate – Power of the Human Rights Code
by Kim Block, Speaking Up BC

More tips for families

  • On opposite sides of the same door in BC schools

    Families and teachers are describing the same failure from two positions inside it. The system survives by keeping them from recognising each other.

  • A summer reading list for education leaders

    The Canary Collective went upstream this week, and the gloves came off. In “Delay, Distract, and Deny”, Wren takes the old public-health parable about pulling bodies from a river and turns…

  • Save Indigenous Education teachers in SD8

    Kootenay Lake School District is moving toward a staffing change in Indigenous Education that families say will remove teacher-led Indigenous Education from elementary and middle schools and replace the teacher…