hand icon with "End collective Punishment in BC Schools"
Woman with cloud over face

What is moral injury?

|

Moral injury refers to the deep psychological and spiritual distress that occurs when a person acts—or is forced to act—in ways that violate their core moral beliefs. It can also occur when someone witnesses harm that they are unable to prevent, stop, or repair. First studied in military contexts, moral injury is now recognised in professions like healthcare, social work, policing, and education—where institutional constraints can force individuals to participate in, or remain complicit with, actions that feel ethically wrong.


How is moral injury different from burnout?

Burnout is often described as a state of emotional exhaustion, overload, and reduced capacity to cope. It’s largely about energy depletion. Moral injury, by contrast, is about ethical rupture. It is not just being tired; it’s the pain of having acted (or failed to act) in a way that violates one’s values—and the shame, grief, or alienation that follows.


What does moral injury look like in schools?

In education, moral injury often arises when teachers are forced to choose between what they believe is right for children and what the system demands. It can look like:

  • Enforcing rules that harm disabled or trauma-affected students
  • Participating in collective punishment despite knowing it is unjust
  • Remaining silent about peer or institutional harm out of fear of retaliation
  • Being unable to provide support to a distressed student due to lack of staff or time

Who experiences moral injury in schools?

While educators are the most visible group impacted, parents and students also experience moral injury—especially when they are forced to accept harm, compromise their values, or participate in systems that violate their sense of justice. Parents may feel torn between advocacy and diplomacy. Students may internalise the belief that speaking up is dangerous or futile.


What helps heal moral injury?

Moral injury cannot be healed by surface-level wellness initiatives. It requires:

  • Acknowledgement of the harm
  • Opportunities for aligned action that restore integrity
  • Collective spaces for processing, reflection, and repair
  • Structural changes that reduce ethical conflict (e.g., banning collective punishment, reducing class size, providing trauma-informed supports)

Why does moral injury matter in school reform?

Moral injury matters because it quietly erodes trust, integrity, and relationships within school communities. Teachers leave the profession not just from stress, but from a deep sense of betrayal. Children lose trust in adults. Families disengage. Naming moral injury allows us to confront the ethical costs of schooling—and to imagine systems where no one has to violate their conscience just to get through the day.

  • On moral injury and collective punishment

    On moral injury and collective punishment

    I did not want to file a complaint. I still don’t—not in the sense that people imagine, with anger or vengeance or a desire for punishment. What I wanted, what I asked for again and again with patience and clarity and increasing despair,…